Well, this one had plenty of talking points. The episode begins with Maud earning her “Rocktorate” and pondering moving to either Ponyville or Ghastly Gorge. Obviously, Pinkie is hoping/pushing for the former. Maud says that it will be a rock-based decision, but could explore less exotic rocks with somepony who ‘gets her.’

Enter Starlight Glimmer. Apart from Maud perhaps lending Starlight an indirect hoof in helping her enslave the village, the two start conversing. Things are off to a good start, but then Pinkie gets a little pushy to make them BFFs and to clingy to Maud. Maud and Starlight also come across a hidden paradise within the gem cave in Ponyville, but again Pinkie appears and you get the picture.

It pushes Maud to choose Ghastly Gorge where she can be alone with “great rocks”. Oh, there are the quarray eels that were introduced in “May the Best Pet Win.” After fleeing form them, Pinkie apologizes to Maud for trying to force friendship between her and Starlight and promise to give her space. Ultimate, Maud finds a space in the Crystal Cave town that she and Starlight discovered.

First off, let’s talk about the pink elephant in the room. This is behavior we have seen before from Pinkie where she gets insecure if she feels she does not have all the friends or the best parties. This is leaning towards Pinkie at her worst a la “A Friend in Deed.” On the other hand, it’s nice to see development for both Maud and Starlight here. This is indeed the first episode in which Starlight appears and Twilight does not as well as prolonged interaction with somepony other that either Twilight or Trixie. Of course, with Maud, we have some of the funniest parts of the episode like Rarity panicking after Maud tells her how ‘common’ chartreuse gems are in the cave.

Already, the speculation is that this season will be about developing characters other than the Mane Six and Spike for the most part, but we’re just four episodes in and there’s a long way to go. So overall, this was a great episode though sometime despite Pinkie rather than because of her.

Post Episode Notes:

  • Third Wheel Pinkie again
  • Maud and Starlight interaction and development
  • Giving Starlight another pony she can relate to
  • Humor, especially with Maud

GRADE:  A-

StatManDan

  • Raffaele Lanza

    Not much to say this time buddy. You pretty much resumed what I think.

    Question: will you review the episodes as they air on Treehouse? Or will you always wait for the DF airings?

    • Shelltoon

      I think they’d rather wait until they air on DF.

    • StatManDan

      I’m going to wait until the DF airings.

      • Raffaele Lanza

        Very well.

  • Charles Stoltz

    Gotta say this. I saw this episode and loved it, Maud is one of my favorite characters, but I feel the episode would have improved if Pinkie Pie’s role had been reduced to a minimum. Here she’s overbearing and annoying and it detracts from the episode completely. I would have loved to see Maud’s interactions with Starlight without Pinkie’s interference.