Cover A by Amy Mebberson

This past Wednesday, Pinkie Pie made her debut in the My Little Pony micro-series and after a disappointing issue last month, Pinkie Pie’s issue brings joy and smiles as the element of laughter should bring, from new writer, Ted Anderson.

That face. She’s staring into my soul!

I have never been so happy to see visible inking in the micro-series. After Tom Zhaler’s abysmal attempt to be show accurate in Twilight’s issue and Tony Fleecs’s consistently amateurish work in Rainbow Dash’s and Fluttershy’s issues, Ben Bates gives a refreshing if not poppy look to the My Little Pony comic universe. It’s not quite as stylized as Andy Price’s penciling or impactful as Amy Mebberson’s work, but it is leagues above Zhaler’s and Fleecs’s work respectively.

Let’s have a look at the story. Pinkie Pie won a contest to go see the GREATEST CLOWN in ALL of EQUESTRIA and she invites Twilight to see the clown, Ponyacci, perform that night. Ponyacci is a reference to Pagliacci, the famous Italian opera. [Editor’s Note:  Not having read the comic being reviewed, I have a sneaking suspicion the reference is actually toward that infamous joke in Watchmen.] Pinkie Pie continues to build up how this stallion has made everyone laugh. However, one pony chimes in claiming Ponyacci could not get him to laugh. Pinkie, being generous, offers him her ticket to see the show instead, but he refuses. After the show, Pinkie Pie and Twilight go backstage to meet the Great Ponyacci, only to see the clown was the stallion from before the show.

Even more of a shock, the performance they saw was Ponyacci’s last. Of course, Pinkie Pie does not want him to stop performing because of how inspirational he was to comedy in Equestria. This is a very relatable situation. Every once in a while you will discover one of your favorite actors, musicians, and athletes decide to retire because of the stress that comes with the job. When Mike Richter retired as goalie for the New York Rangers at the age of 35, it was sad to see him leave the sport. But he left due to the constant injuries and he just was not at the top of his game.

Like Pinkie Pie, however, she tries everything in her power to get the famous comedian to come out of retirement. After putting on an extravagant performance for the entertainer, with Twilight in charge of props and background music, he still rejects to come out of retirement. However, he ends up critiquing the performance to how she could have improved. This gives Pinkie Pie the idea Ponyacci should teach about comedy and clowning around.

This brings up another reason why the comic is really enjoyable, Pinkie’s true nature. Pinkie Pie, while very happy-go-lucky, is also very smart when she’s put on the spot. Examples include “A Friend in Deed,” when she recognized Matilda had the same photo album as Cranky Doodle Donkey, and “Too Many Pinkie Pies” where she gives a brilliant suggestion to determine who the is the real Pinkie Pie. The same applies to the comic in question. When observing Ponyacci’s observations, she suggested that teaching could actually be beneficial to the stallion without completely retiring from comedy.

My Little Pony Micro-Series #5 featuring Pinkie Pie is a zany, optimistic, and fun-filled slice-of-life story that captures Pinkie Pie’s nature from the show perfectly as if Amy Keating Rogers was writing the character herself. With a cartoony feel in the artwork and a heartwarming moral about not giving up on your dreams, Pinkie Pie’s issue excels beyond the call of duty.

5 out of 5 stars

  • Anonymous

    I agree, even Rarity’s one is still my favorite, this came second. It’s amazing.

    • You’re absolutely right about this and the Rarity issue being the best of the bunch. I honestly can’t decide which of those two I like better. Both of the main stories are pretty much equally awesome in my estimation, and the art style of both is beautiful. The Rarity issue has the cool side story about Hayseed Turnip Truck. On the other hand, while the Rarity comic has a funny joke about making a Friendship Report, the Pinkie issue has an *actual* fully written heartwarming report at the end, which instantly adds several points in its favor.

      They’re both so awesome- I just can’t decide!

    • Cheerilee1980

      Rarity ranks in my favorites too.

      And this comic looks great.

  • Anonymous

    Just out of curiosity, will you be doing a review of the Rarity issue of this micro-series?

    • Anonymous

      Sadly, no. Even though I love the issue, that ship has sailed. But you may see a review in video form in the near future.

    • Screenplay

      Btw this is the author.

  • The editor is correct. The guys at Bronyville did an interview with Ted Anderson back in March. On the show, he explicitly stated that the comic was based on the Watchmen joke. (Episode 96 @ 1:15:46)

  • Pingback: Pinkie Pie review roundup | My Site/Blog()

  • Pingback: “My Little Pony Micro-Series #6…featuring Applejack” Review plus Final Rankings | Derpy Hooves News()